Finding The Right Legal Help
Look for a music/entertainment attorney who represents artists, rather than a general business attorney who occasionally reviews entertainment contracts. Your lawyer should ideally be able to help with the whole business side of the band: record labels, management, booking agencies, promoters, publishing, licensing, sponsorships, publicity agreements, and intellectual property.
The American Bar Association describes entertainment law as involving contracts plus intellectual-property issues such as copyright and trademarks, and recent ABA guidance specifically emphasizes the importance of understanding who owns the compositions, recordings, and other rights in a record deal.
1. Start With These Questions About the Lawyer
I’d make your first interview fairly direct:
“How much of your practice is devoted to music and entertainment law?”
Then ask:
- How many recording artists do you currently represent?
- How many bands?
- How many record-label agreements have you negotiated?
- How many booking/agency agreements?
- How many management agreements?
- Do you represent artists or primarily labels, managers, promoters and agencies?
- Have you represented artists at our career level?
- What genres of music do your clients represent?
- Can you provide references from current or former artist clients?
- Who will actually handle our account—you or an associate?
- Will we have direct access to you when an important deal comes up?
The ABA specifically recommends asking about a lawyer’s experience, areas of practice, who will actually work on the matter, fees, and the terms of the engagement.
One question I particularly like:
“If you were representing our band, what are the three biggest legal or business risks you would want us to address before we start signing contracts?”
A good attorney should have a thoughtful answer.
2. Make Sure the Lawyer Represents YOU
This is critical.
You want to know:
“Who is your client?”
If a lawyer represents the label, booking agency, manager, or promoter in a particular transaction, that creates a fundamentally different relationship.
For your band, you want someone whose job is to protect the band’s interests.
The ABA emphasizes that identifying the actual client is an important ethical issue in legal representation.
3. Ask About Conflicts of Interest
I’d ask:
“Do you currently represent any record labels, managers, booking agencies, promoters, or other companies that could potentially negotiate against us?”
And:
“If a conflict arises between our interests and another client of yours, what happens?”
This becomes particularly important once you’re dealing with multiple players in the music business.
4. Ask Exactly How They Charge
Don’t be embarrassed to discuss money immediately.
Ask:
- Hourly rate?
- Flat fee?
- Retainer?
- Percentage of deals?
- Minimum billing?
- How are phone calls billed?
- Emails?
- Reviewing contracts?
- Negotiations?
- Travel?
- Expenses?
- Associate time?
- Paralegal time?
And:
“Can you give us an estimate of what it normally costs you to negotiate a typical record-label agreement?”
Then ask:
“What would cause that estimate to increase?”
Get the fee arrangement in a written engagement letter. The ABA notes that the engagement agreement establishes what the lawyer will do and how the client will pay.
5. Find Out Whether They Think Beyond Individual Contracts
This is where I think you can get significant value from the right lawyer.
You don’t want someone who simply says:
“Send me the contract and I’ll review it.”
You want someone who can say:
“Before you sign this, let’s make sure your entire business structure is ready.”
For example:
The Band Itself
- Who owns the band name?
- Who owns the recordings?
- Who owns the equipment?
- Who owns the merchandise?
- How are revenues divided?
- What happens if someone leaves?
- What happens if the band breaks up?
- Who can sign contracts?
- Who can spend band money?
- Who owns the social-media accounts?
- Who controls the band’s website and domain?
The ABA’s recent music-law guidance specifically recommends treating a band as a business and considering an entity such as an LLC with an operating agreement establishing members’ rights, contributions and expectations.
6. Have the Lawyer Help You Establish the Band’s Business Structure
If you haven’t already done this, I’d ask:
“Should the band operate through an LLC or other legal entity?”
Then:
“Can you help us create an operating agreement between the band members?”
That agreement can address things like:
- Ownership percentages
- Revenue distribution
- Voting
- Expenses
- Band bank account
- Who can sign contracts
- What happens when a member leaves
- What happens if someone dies
- Ownership of the band name
- Ownership of recordings
- Songwriting
- Merchandise
- Social-media accounts
- Breaking up the band
Do this before the big contracts start coming in, rather than after there is a disagreement.
7. Record-Label Contracts
You’ve already asked about this, and I’d make sure your lawyer is prepared to analyze:
Masters
- Who owns them?
- License vs. assignment
- Length of term
- Reversion
- Re-recording restrictions
Money
- Advance
- Royalty percentage
- Royalty calculation
- Recoupable expenses
- Marketing expenses
- Recording expenses
- Cross-collateralization
- Accounting
- Audit rights
Commitment
- Number of albums
- Options
- Release requirements
- Marketing obligations
- Termination provisions
Creative Control
- Producer
- Songs
- Artwork
- Singles
- Videos
- Release dates
The distinction between the sound recording copyright and the underlying musical composition is particularly important.
8. Booking-Agent Contracts
If you’re hiring a booking agency, ask your attorney to examine:
- Exclusivity
- Territory
- Term
- Commission percentage
- What revenue is commissionable
- Existing bookings
- Festivals
- Corporate events
- Merchandise
- Cancellation
- Deposits
- Force majeure
- Who receives performance payments
- Who pays expenses