Since this is your first record-label deal, I would approach it as a business transaction, not simply an exciting opportunity to get your music released. The contract can determine who owns your recordings, how long you’re committed, how royalties are calculated, what expenses are charged against your earnings, and what happens if the relationship doesn’t work out.
Most importantly: don’t sign the label’s contract before an entertainment attorney who regularly represents recording artists has reviewed it. The cost of that review can be tiny compared with the long-term value of the rights you’re potentially giving away.
1. First Question: What Kind of Deal Are They Actually Offering?
Don’t assume that “record deal” means one particular thing.
Ask:
“Is this a traditional recording agreement, a license agreement, a distribution deal, or something else?”
The distinction is enormous.
Generally:
- Traditional recording deal: label may own the masters and fund recording/marketing.
- License deal: you may retain ownership while giving the label exclusive rights to exploit the recordings for a defined period.
- Distribution deal: label/distributor primarily handles getting your music to market while you retain substantially more ownership/control.
The contract—not what the label calls the deal—determines the actual rights.
2. Who Owns Our Masters?
This should be near the top of your list.
Ask:
“Who owns the master recordings we’re delivering to you?”
Then ask:
- Do we retain ownership?
- Is the label receiving ownership or an exclusive license?
- How long does the label control the recordings?
- Do the masters ever revert to us?
- What happens if the label stops exploiting the recordings?
- What happens if the label goes out of business?
- Can the label sell or transfer our masters to another company?
- Can we approve such a transfer?
A master recording and the underlying song/composition are separate rights, so don’t assume that giving a label rights to the recording automatically answers what happens to your songwriting/publishing.
3. What Happens to Our Songwriting and Publishing?
This is especially important if members of your band wrote the songs.
Ask:
“Does this agreement affect our publishing rights in any way?”
You want to know whether the label is receiving any rights to:
- Songs
- Lyrics
- Compositions
- Publishing
- Mechanical royalties
- Synchronization income
A recording agreement and a publishing agreement are different things. Make sure the label isn’t quietly obtaining rights to the underlying compositions through broad language in the recording contract.
4. How Much Money Are We Actually Getting?
Don’t stop at:
“We’re offering you a $50,000 advance.”
Ask:
“What is the total advance, and exactly how is it paid?”
For example:
- $10,000 on signing
- $20,000 when recording begins
- $20,000 on delivery
Then ask:
“What portion of that money is recoupable?”
An advance generally isn’t simply free money. Under many recording agreements, the label recoups the advance and specified costs from the artist’s royalty account before additional royalties become payable.
5. This Is One of the Biggest Questions: What Is Recoupable?
Ask them to give you a written list.
Potentially recoupable expenses can include:
- Advance
- Recording
- Producer
- Mixing
- Mastering
- Musicians
- Videos
- Marketing
- Promotion
- Tour support
- Other expenses
The exact contract language matters enormously.
Ask:
“Please show us every category of expense that can be charged against our royalty account.”
Then ask:
“Are there any expenses the label can incur without our approval that we will nevertheless have to recoup?”
Recoupment provisions can dramatically affect when an artist actually begins receiving royalty payments.
6. Ask Them to Demonstrate the Royalty Calculation
Don’t accept:
“You’ll receive 15% royalties.”
Ask:
“15% of what?”
Is it calculated from:
- Retail price?
- Wholesale price?
- Label’s net receipts?
- Streaming revenue?
- Revenue after deductions?
Then ask the label to give you a hypothetical example.
For example:
“If one of our songs generates $100,000 in revenue for the label, walk us through exactly how much the band receives and every deduction that occurs before we get paid.”
That’s an excellent test of whether you actually understand the economics of the deal.
7. Watch for Cross-Collateralization
This is a term I would have your attorney specifically examine.
In simplified terms, cross-collateralization can allow an unrecouped balance from one project or account to be recovered from royalties generated by another project or income stream.
For a new band, this can materially affect your ability to start earning royalties from later releases.
Ask:
“Are our albums and projects accounted for separately, or can an unrecouped balance from one release be charged against another?”
8. How Many Albums Are We Actually Committing To?
This is another major issue for a new band.
You may hear:
“We’re signing you for one album.”
But the contract might actually say:
One album + multiple label options.
Ask:
- How many albums are guaranteed?
- How many options does the label have?
- Who controls whether an option is exercised?
- How long is each option period?
- Can the band decline an option?
- Can we leave if the label doesn’t exercise an option?
- Does the royalty rate increase on subsequent albums?
- Does the advance increase?
Record contracts commonly use option periods in which the label—not the artist—controls whether subsequent albums are acquired.
9. What Does the Label Actually Promise to Do?
This may be the most important business question of all.